Challenge
When a brand offered higher Cash Back rates than competitors, they saw stronger lifetime spend of new-to-files (NTFs) versus their competitors. When Cash Back rates dropped to roughly equivalent levels, more of the spend shifted to competitors.
Shoppers started receiving significantly better rates at the competitor, and as a result the lifetime spend of NTFs was higher than with the brand. The competitor had been aggressive with their approach:
- Leveraged Price Magic to conquest.
- Ran a higher average base Cash Back rate (4%) than the brand (1%).
- Participated in Q4 Cash Back promotions vs. 0 from the brand.
- Offered a competitive targeted 10% Cash Back.